Pakistan allays Indian fears on Iranian gas
pipeline
By Nadeem Iqbal
ISLAMABAD - Pakistan's military government has ordered work started on a
pipeline that can carry natural gas from Iran and Central Asia to India,
but not many expect it to serve its intended purpose.
Military ruler Pervez Musharraf last week gave the go-ahead for the
construction of the 1500 kilometer pipeline. Musharraf also disclosed that
Pakistan is negotiating the purchase of natural gas from the Gulf nations
of Qatar and Oman and Central Asian Turkmenistan.
Although the government has not said so explicitly, the decision to build
the pipeline is clearly aimed at the energy-hungry Indian market. Pakistan
is expected to earn about $600 million annually in transit fees alone. A
top government official, who did not want to be identified, told IPS that
while a large part of the energy imports from Iran, Central Asia and the
Gulf would be used for Pakistan's own needs, cash-strapped Islamabad is
keen to sell the surplus to India.
The government's decision on the pipeline is significant, coming soon
after India and Iran held discussions in mid-May on energy cooperation,
including piping Iranian natural gas to India. Pakistan's Foreign Ministry
Spokesman Iftikhar Murshed had told reporters last week that Islamabad was
not opposed to the idea of piping Iranian gas to India through Pakistani
territory. ''India has adopted several considerations concerning the
project, yet Pakistan has never objected to it,'' he said.
According to reports from Tehran, visiting Indian Foreign Minister Jaswant
Singh had proposed shipping gas in liquid form from Iran to India as an
alternative option to a land pipeline route through Pakistan. However,
Iran was reportedly not in favor of this. New Delhi and Tehran have now
set up a joint panel to review the technical and security aspects of the
proposal to pipe the gas from Iran to India.
In a statement issued in April, the Indian Foreign Office had said India
was not interested in importing gas that had to pass over Pakistani
territory. Nuclear rivals India and Pakistan, who have gone to war three
times over Kashmir, are considered unlikely to reach agreement on transit
for Gulf and Central Asian gas through Pakistani territory.
Senior government officials who have been closely involved with diplomatic
negotiations on the issue, told IPS on condition of anonymity that Indian
fears of Pakistan cutting off India's energy supplies in the event of
political tension were unfounded. Although Islamabad and New Delhi may not
be friends, Pakistan would not want to annoy ''tested friend'' Iran which
is closely involved in developing Pakistan's oil industry, they pointed
out. Iran is helping Pakistan build a $1.1 billion refinery, expected to
be ready next year. The 130,000 barrels per day plant would double
Pakistan's domestic petroleum refining capacity.
Experts say there are no major technical obstacles to building pipelines
over Pakistani territory to take gas from Turkmenistan or Iran to Pakistan
and India. Nor is there any problem in taking gas from Qatar to the two
countries through a coastal pipeline.
Energy analysts point out that the use of natural gas in Pakistan and
India has grown substantially in the past two decades. Estimates by the
International Energy Agency suggest that India's demand for gas would
swell four-fold by the year 2010. It would more than double in Pakistan by
then. At current production rates, the proven fuel reserves in both
nations are estimated to last for no more than 40 years. In the absence of
major new discoveries in these countries, India and Pakistan would have to
look overseas to meet their energy needs, say experts.
According to Toufiq Siddiqui, President of the Hawaii-based Global
Environment and Energy and a former regional energy advisor to the United
Nations, Pakistan and India have much to gain from joint gas imports.
Siddiqui has calculated that each of the two poor nations could save
several hundreds of millions of dollars every year by jointly importing
Central Asian gas.
Islamabad's keenness for gas imports was evident in Musharraf's early May
visit to Turkmenistan where he held talks on a year-old proposal for a
pipeline from the Central Asian nation to Pakistan passing through
Afghanistan. In April 1999, Pakistan, Turkmenistan and the Taleban rulers
of Kabul, had agreed to revive the $2 billion gas pipeline project. This
would lay a 1.2 meter thick, 1,400 kilometer long pipeline from
Turkmenistan's Daulatabad gas field through Afghanistan to Multan in
central Pakistan.
Pakistan wants to reduce its oil import bill and has declared gas as the
fuel of choice for its future energy needs.