Tough talk continues despite peace demands
By Ranjit Dev Raj
NEW DELHI - India's Defense Minister George Fernandes advised parliament
on Wednesday of a massing of militants backed by the Pakistani army along
the border, hinting at a rapidly deteriorating security environment.
Fernandes said the Indian government was ''aware that hundreds of heavily
armed mercenaries backed by enhanced troop strength had been amassed by
Pakistan along the line of control (LoC)'' in the northern part of the
disputed territory of Kashmir.
He also spoke of reports of radar deployment and induction of additional
units of the Pakistan army in the coastal marshlands of Kutch especially
in the border villages of Keti Bandar, Shah Bandar, Musafirkhana, Nagar
Parkar and Mithi.
Both Kashmir and Kutch saw action in which warplanes were downed and heavy
artillery fire exchanged during an undeclared ten-week war between the two
countries that began in mid-May last year. But most of the fighting was in
the Kargil area of the LoC which separates the Pakistan and Indian
controlled sections of Kashmir.
Since the war ended on intervention by US President Bill Clinton, there
have been 1,659 violent incidents in Kashmir involving armed militants
who, India claims, infiltrated across the LoC into Indian territory.
Fernandes informed Parliament that a total of 845 ''terrorists'' were
killed in these incidents which, he said, also claimed the lives of 175
Indian armed forces personnel.
Most of the other victims were ordinary people caught in the fighting,
including 35 Sikhs massacred in Anantnag district on March 19, hours
before Clinton began a five-day tour of India.
Clinton who made a brief stopover in Pakistan on March 25 at the end of
the India tour urged a resumption of diplomatic dialogue but warned
against attempts to ''redraw borders in blood''. His words were echoed at
a press conference Monday by visiting British Foreign Secretary Robin Cook
who broadly agreed with the Indian view that ''a successful dialogue
without an end to violence will be too challenging a task for diplomats.''
An Indian foreign ministry official interpreted Cook's statement as
''recognition within the international community that the absence of
cross-border terrorism is an essential element in resumption of meaningful
dialogue between India and Pakistan''.
India has steadfastly refused to resume talks until it saw evidence on the
ground of Pakistan stopping a ''proxy war'' being fought for control over
Indian-administered Kashmir using heavily armed insurgents. Pakistan has
denied militarily backing the armed militancy and recently interior
minister in the military government Lt Gen Moinuddin Haider warned at a
press conference of impending action against ''sectarian groups''.
But on Tuesday, the Pakistan-based Harkat ul-Mujahideen group, banned in
the US for terrorist activities, responded by saying that ''nobody dared
stop its fighters from entering India-occupied Kashmir.'' The group's
leader Fazlur Rehman Khalil was reported saying it was not bothered by
''redundant statements'' issued by the interior minister and considered
the US itself as the ''biggest terrorist''. Khalil said in a statement
that neither the Pakistani government, nor India nor the US could ''stop
or control'' the ongoing jihad (holy war) to liberate Kashmir.
On Tuesday, Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee announced constitution of
a special ''group of ministers'' which would ''review the national
security system in its entirety''. Vajpayee said, the group, including
Fernandes, Foreign Minister Jaswant Singh and Finance Minister Yashwant
Sinha, would act on the recommendations of a committee which had reviewed
the conflict at Kargil on the LoC.
The committee, headed by defense expert K Subrahmanyam, had noted that the
''Kargil experience, the continuing proxy war, and the prevailing
nuclearized security environment justified review of the national security
system''.
India's policy of refusing to open dialogue with Pakistan's military
government while attempting to isolate it diplomatically may have found
endorsement from Cook but has come up for severe criticism from foreign
policy experts and opposition leaders. Said Mani Shankar Aiyar, Congress
party leader and former career diplomat, ''You can kick Pakistan out of
international fora but you cannot kick Pakistan out of South Asia.''
Saner voices were also heard, earlier this month, from the Pakistan-India
People's Forum for Peace and Democracy in a declaration following its
fifth convention in the city of Bangalore on April 8. ''Defying pressures
from the government of India and Pakistan and ultra-nationalist forces the
forum of 500 delegates from both countries renewed their pledge to work
for peace,'' said convenors Tapan Bose and Feroz Mehdi.
The convention took place after a court rejected a petition filed by a
Hindu fundamentalist group which claimed that the Pakistani delegation of
more than 150 people consisted of agents from Pakistan's Inter Services
Intelligence.
The declaration itself said the fifth convention met during a ''critical
time of war, threats of war, nuclearization and persistent obstacles
placed in the path of the assembly of peace-loving peoples of the two
countries.'' It demanded a ''democratic resolution of the Kashmir
problem,'' and awareness of the ''increasing danger of deliberate or
accidental war breaking out with the risk of any conflict escalating to
the level of nuclear holocaust''.
The declaration also demanded immediate resumption of dialogue by the two
countries and a ''reversal of current military build-ups, horizontal and
vertical denuclearization and a comprehensive no-war pact.''