Anwar's party lays ground for a new era
By Anil Netto
PENANG - As Malaysian opposition leader Anwar Ibrahim's sodomy case meanders
its way through the courts, the spotlight has shifted to how his party is
preparing for the possible outcome.
A guilty verdict in the high-stakes case would be a significant blow to his
opposition People's Alliance (Pakatan Rakyat - PKR), which hopes to capitalize
on significant gains it made against the ruling Barisan Nasional (BN) coalition
at the last general election in 2008.
Although Anwar was legally barred from contesting that poll, he was
instrumental in bringing together the disparate parties during
the campaign and then in forging a cohesive opposition alliance. Now in power
in four of the federation’s 13 states, Pakatan Rakyat has trained its sights on
capturing federal power at the next polls, which must be held by 2013.
Anwar's role in its prospects cannot be underestimated. The big question now is
if and for how long the opposition icon will remain free. Anwar's legal team
has challenged the prosecution by appealing to higher courts, but so far their
tactics have been thwarted.
"He has to challenge the process at every stage to expose the extent of the
perceived travesty of justice he faces," says a Kuala Lumpur-based political
commentator. "In the process, he suffers the unfortunate perception among the
uncomprehending that he is deliberately delaying the process of justice. In
fact, it is an apparent deprivation of that process that he has been suffering
and highlighting through his appeals."
In his latest legal challenge, Anwar tried to get the sodomy charge dropped
after it was revealed that the former Anwar aide who had accused his ex-boss of
sodomy was involved in an affair with a female prosecuting team member. The
judge accepted that the relationship between the ex-aide and the female did
exist, but noted that she was just a junior member of the prosecution team.
The trial proceedings appear to hold an advantage for the BN as Anwar spends
precious time huddled with lawyers as they formulate their legal defense
strategy, said Xavier Jayakumar, of the People's Justice Party (Keadilan),
Anwar's party. "At every level we ask for reasons, we are hitting a brick wall.
The judiciary feels the case has to go on. We are preparing for the worst - but
all said and done, Keadilan has to go on."
Since the watershed poll in 2008, Keadilan has been embarrassed by a series of
defections of its elected representatives to the ruling BN coalition. The
political drift has been stemmed - for now - and the party is now gearing up
for watershed party elections this November. For the first time, ordinary party
members - 400,000 of them in 218 branches across the country - will get to vote
directly in elections for the top leaders in the party.
The move is aimed at democratizing and widening the intra-party election
process. Until now, voting for top leadership posts - not only in Keadilan but
in other local political parties as well - is usually carried out by delegates
attending a national-level general assembly, the delegates being first chosen
by the party's divisions or branches.
Keadilan's more open approach will begin with branch annual general meetings
and branch elections across the country from September 17, finalization of
nominations from the branches for top national-level posts in October, and
climaxing with polling by members for these posts in November. The experiment
will provide an opportunity to gauge to what extent members support Anwar's
close allies in key positions of power.
Anwar himself occupies a vaguely designated and unelected "ketua umum"
or "general chief" post that puts him at the top of the Keadilan hierarchy,
according to the party’s website. His wife, Wan Azizah, is the party president
and her deputy is the veteran politician Syed Husin Ali. However, speculation
has risen that Syed Husin may step down for health or family reasons.
If that happens, it would open the number two party spot for a heavyweight
contest that could pit Anwar loyalist and party vice-president Azmin Ali
against Zaid Ibrahim, a former BN cabinet minister who quit the federal
government in protest at the use of the harsh Internal Security Act to detain
critics without trial.
While Azmin is seen as a proven party loyalist and Anwar ally who is unlikely
to jump ship, Zaid has quickly emerged as a liberal figure who is especially
popular among the minorities for his inclusive vision. While some party
supporters contend both Azmin and Zaid are needed by the party, some critical
observers feel that there are still too many ex-United Malays National
Organization (UMNO) politicians in the party.
These observers feel a reformist party like Keadilan should project more new
faces without such BN baggage at the highest ranks of the party. One Kuala
Lumpur-based political commentator told Asia Times Online that the party needs
a leader who has the intellectual stature and the Muslim rectitude to counter
coalition partner PAS on Islamic issues.
Already, certain candidates - even at the branch level - are jostling and
maneuvering for position and mobilizing support for their candidatures. Press
conferences have been held to show support from PKR parliamentarians for
certain national-level candidates in the PKR polls.
These crude bids at shaping party opinion are reminiscent of BN-style power
politics, say political analysts. Political scientist Farish Noor believes
Malaysians are witnessing an attempt to consolidate control of the party in the
hands of Anwar loyalists in anticipation of the outcome of the Anwar trial.
"However, PKR is now perhaps the most transparent party in Malaysia and none of
this [maneuvering] is happening unnoticed."
The well-known commentator said he is concerned about what he views as a
personality cult surrounding Anwar and his preeminent role in the party
leadership. "Should the trend lead to further glorification of Anwar and the
'personality cult' around him, the party risks becoming a joke like
[Cambodia's] Sam Rainsy Party that was named after its leader."
Farish recalls that during Anwar's tenure as leader of the Malaysian Muslim
Youth Movement (known by its Malay acronym ABIM), the movement was criticized
as the 'Anwar Bin Ibrahim Movement', a reference to the acronym, due to the
charismatic leader's dominant role.
Keadilan and its coalition partners now fancy themselves within sniffing
distance of federal power, and this in turn has drawn a more intense contest
for leadership positions. "It's quite natural," says Keadilan's Jayakumar, of
the canvassing for support. "Every branch in Selangor [state] is likely to see
a challenge, even from newcomers. In the long run, we are definitely looking
forward to going to Putrajaya [the seat of federal government]; we are
preparing for it; we are quite sure of retaining the state."
He says there are now two prevailing perceptions: "The mainstream media are
showing that the BN are going ahead and bringing about change and that Pakatan
is in a mess. But on the ground, there are a lot of positive vibrations in
Penang and Selangor; the people on the ground know what is happening and they
are positive we should go on."
One rising politician who has shot into the limelight is Anwar's articulate
daughter, Nurul Izzah, who continues to burnish her political credentials. She
has tackled head on the right-wing Malay nationalist group Perkasa (which means
Empower), made up largely of UMNO members and supporters, by challenging them
to a debate.
Learning the hard way about Malaysia’s rough and tumble politics during Anwar's
incarceration a dozen years ago on corruption and sodomy charges, and since
then emerging as a leading inclusive voice in the party, the 30-year-old
parliamentarian is already being viewed by some as a possible future leader.
For now, though, it's the party’s rank and file who will guide its course if
history repeats itself and Anwar is jailed for a second time.
Anil Netto is a Penang-based writer.
(Copyright 2010 Asia Times Online (Holdings) Ltd. All rights reserved. Please
contact us about
sales, syndication and
republishing.)
Head
Office: Unit B, 16/F, Li Dong Building, No. 9 Li Yuen Street East,
Central, Hong Kong Thailand Bureau:
11/13 Petchkasem Road,
Hua Hin, Prachuab Kirikhan, Thailand 77110
