Vietnam loses out on Oscar glory
Tran Dinh Thanh Lam
HO CHI MINH CITY - A Vietnamese film that missed out on the short list for
Sunday's Oscars nonetheless offers a glimpse into how Vietnam and the United
States are healing their decades-old war wounds, as well as how that war still
generates emotional debate.
Dung Dot, or Don't Burn , is based on the wartime diary of a 27-year-old
female Vietcong physician Dang Thuy Tram, who was shot dead by US soldiers in
the early 1960s as US military involvement escalated in the country.
The movie was Vietnam's representative in the best foreign language category of
the 82nd annual awards of the US Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences,
which was won by the
Argentine film Secret in Their Eyes. Another war movie, The Hurt Locker,
swept the awards with six Oscars for its jarring portrayal of a US bomb
disposal squad in Iraq.
The title of Don't Burn comes from a throwaway remark made when Tram's
diary was originally found more than three decades ago by a US soldier, Fred
Whitehurst, who handed it to his South Vietnamese translator. After reading
some pages the translator told his friend not to burn it as "there's already
fire in it".
"Last night I dreamed of peace. I came back and saw everybody. Oh, the dream of
peace and independence has burned in the hearts of 30 million people for so
long," read part of Tram's diary.
Tram's dream of peace formed the core of the movie, which was scripted and
directed by Dang Nhat Minh. Last Night I Dreamed of Peace is also the
title of the diary's English translation, which was published in the United
States in 2007.
It was published a year after Whitehurst, who had kept the diary for 35 years,
finally returned it to Tram's family. It has since been translated into many
languages and hailed by Vietnamese media and officials as the work of a young
intellectual who had devoted her life to the revolutionary cause.
There have been many movies about the Vietnam War but Minh was determined that
Tram's diary would be different and not become propaganda.
"The film is not about the war. Instead, it is about the beauty and humanity of
Tram," said Minh, also known the acclaimed war film When the Tenth Month Comes.
He said he wanted a film that could help further bring together the former
warring countries, which in the past decades have reconciled diplomatic,
economic and political relations although issues like the impact of the use of
Agent Orange and remains of US soldiers missing in action remain.
The war in Vietnam took place from 1959 to 1975, a conflict that the US
government entered to stop a takeover of South Vietnam - which it and other
allies backed - by the communist North. Referred to as the American War by the
Vietnamese, the conflict led to the deaths of 3 to 4 million Vietnamese in the
north and south and more than 58,000 US soldiers.
The country was unified in 1976, after the North Vietnamese army captured Ho
Chi Minh City, then called Saigon, in April 1975.
The film hints that reconciliation among the peoples of the two countries has
indeed taken root, although it does not explicitly show facets like the
friendship that developed between Whitehurst and Tram's mother and sisters
after he returned the diary and visited them several times afterward.
"It would have been difficult to make this movie without the help of American
war veterans Fred Whitehurst and Robert Whitehurst who shared their wartime
memories with me," said Minh, adding that seven US actors had roles in the
movie.
Some responses to the movie highlight how the peace theme in this war movie
reaches out to audiences in the United States. Many overseas Vietnamese and
lecturers and students have taken part in lively discussions after showings of Don't
Burn in several US universities, news reports say.
At the Cantor Film Center in New York City, John McAutiff, managing director of
the New-York based Conciliation and Development Foundation, thanked Minh for "a
movie about war that doesn't have hatred, only love, the dream of peace and the
brotherhood of soldiers".
But while US audiences may have rapturous applause and tears after watching Don't
Burn, overseas Vietnamese tend to be more skeptical.
Screenings of the film have raised doubts that despite its emotional appeal,
the movie failed to look deep enough into other key issues, including US
intervention in the region and the divisions that still remain between the
north and southern parts of the country owing to their different political
pasts.
Some Vietnamese students have said the film shirked essential issues such as
the legitimacy of the war, whether the conflict was a liberation war or a civil
war, and the plight of the people and soldiers of South Vietnam after US troops
pulled out in 1975.
"It's weird that the film is aimed at generating reconciliation between ancient
foes," University of California in Los Angeles student Tran Thanh was quoted as
saying. "For most Americans, the war in Vietnam is already a thing of the past.
Reconciliation with Americans is like hitting a door that has been already
widely opened. It is with the southern Vietnamese that reconciliation should
go," Thanh said.
"Viewers have their own thinking and I respect their different thinking," said
Minh, whose film also won the audience award at Japan's Fukuoka International
Film Festival in September 2009.
He added that there is an element that includes South Vietnam, since Don't Burn
touched on the whereabouts of the South Vietnamese sergeant who kept Tram's
diary from being burned. The film, however, does not shed light on what
happened to this soldier, whose name is not mentioned. Some Vietnamese news
reports said the soldier's name was Huan.
"Tram's diary would never exist without the civilized and humane attitude of a
South Army sergeant. But he only deserves a word for form's sake at the end of
the movie," said a bitter comment on Talawas, one of most prestigious
independent Vietnamese websites.
Head
Office: Unit B, 16/F, Li Dong Building, No. 9 Li Yuen Street East,
Central, Hong Kong Thailand Bureau:
11/13 Petchkasem Road,
Hua Hin, Prachuab Kirikhan, Thailand 77110
