A reversal for Indonesia's Islamist party By Gary LaMoshi
DENPASAR, Bali - Five years ago, Indonesia's Prosperous Justice Party pulled
off a stunning electoral coup, winning 7.2% of the national vote and topping
all parties with 22% in Jakarta, the nation's capital. This Islamic party,
known locally as PKS (Partai Kedailan Sejahtera), became the country's hottest
political commodity alongside another new player, retired general Susilo
Bambang Yudhoyono - known as SBY - and his Democratic Party. Both attracted
grassroots support by promising a clean break from the established top
political parties.
Yudhoyono went on to win the presidency, while PKS saw its leader Hidayat Nur
Wahid chosen as speaker of the People's Consultative Assembly (DPR), a
high-profile platform for extending
the party's electoral success. But while Yudhoyono is the frontrunner for the
presidential polls scheduled for this July, experts predict that religious
parties, including the PKS, are headed for their worst ever showing at the
April legislative elections.
With its strong mass network through mosques, PKS might yet produce another
surprise at the polls. But the party has seemingly failed to capitalize on its
strong showing in 2004 by consolidating the Islamist vote or expanding the
party's base. The PKS leadership's inability to decide on which path to follow
might be one reason the party has not progressed on par with SBY's Democratic
Party.
A bigger problem may be that what was fresh and new in 2004 has become just
another party in 2009. "For many people - particularly Muslims - PKS has not
seemed to have much distinction vis-a-vis other parties," said Syarif
Hidayatullah State Islamic University history professor Azyumardi Azra. "In the
parliament and also in provincial parliaments, like in Jakarta [where PKS holds
the most seats], PKS has failed to fight for peoples' interests. PKS has
[gotten] lost in the political struggles and intrigues."
In 2004, PKS won votes on a staunch anti-corruption platform that resonated
with voters, while keeping its advocacy of instituting sharia (Islamic)
law in the background. Opposing corruption is always a crowd pleaser, but
analysts predict it will not be nearly as effective for PKS at the upcoming
polls. "It is a case of Parkinson's Law," former presidential spokesman Wimar
Witoelar believes, meaning that PKS has become a victim of its own success. "As
major parties became irrelevant, PKS came up representing a breed of young,
idealistic and religious people. Success has given it access to higher
electoral goals for which it does not have candidates."
No to limos
As DPR speaker, Nur Wahid refused a new car and hotel suite that came with the
job. Those gestures were meant to set a tone for politicians to treat public
service as a public trust rather than a platform for personal gain. Neither Nur
Wahid's example nor his leadership has changed DPR's reputation as a place
where passing legislation takes a back seat to political grandstanding and
graft. PKS may even have gotten caught up in the political culture it ran
against. PKS secretary general Anis Matta has been accused of soliciting
"contributions" from office seekers, charges Matta and the party deny.
While PKS has foundered, Yudhoyono and his administration have successfully
built a reputation for prosecuting corruption. Never mind that Yudhoyono
remains obsequious to deposed president Suharto's clan and his former military
colleagues. For the public, the anti-corruption issue largely belongs to the
Democratic Party.
If PKS was not ready for the prime time in 2004, as Witoelar suggests, it
hasn't made significant progress since. That may be due to splits in its ranks.
"One is the faction Keadilan(Justice), which tries to hold fast to PKS
idealism such as Hidayat Nurwahid," Azra, a leading moderate Muslim thinker,
explains. "On the other hand, there is the faction of Kesejahteraan [Welfare],
which includes Anis Matta, it is very pragmatic and tends to have a very strong
interest in material well-being."
On the campaign trail, this split plays out as an identity crisis, according to
Azra.
PKS seem to have lost its original identity. During the campaign
now, it asserts that it can be "red" [the symbol of former president Megawati
Sukarnoputri's Democratic Party of Struggle], "yellow" [the symbol of Suharto's
former ruling vehicle the Golkar Party], or "green" [the symbol of Abdurrahman
Wahid's secular Muslim Awakening Party and the moderate Islamist United
Development Party], for the sake of the Indonesian nation-state. So, PKS tries
to show itself as a party that can accept "any color" or pluralism. As a
result, the party seems to have compromised its original identity which is
"pristine Islam".
Some party officials are even talking up the
possibility of Nur Wahid replacing Golkar chairman Jusuf Kalla as Yudhoyono's
running mate.
In practical terms, PKS has yet to formulate a defining issue that has mass
appeal, while walking the fine line between promoting sharia and
maintaining credibility as inclusive, or at least non-threatening, to the
country's 30 million-plus non-Muslims. Even among the Muslim majority, there's
limited enthusiasm for sharia.
But the legislation most closely identified with PKS in this session of
parliament is the controversial pornography bill passed last year. Aside from
limiting freedom of speech and expression, the bill's vague provisions could be
used to outlaw ceremonial dances and other traditional practices of not just
minorities but Muslim groups. Most troublingly, the bill allows enforcement by
citizens, effectively legalizing vigilantism and aligning PKS with violent
fringe factions such as the Islamic Defenders Front (FPI), that regularly
attack opponents with armed mobs.
Victim mentality
In 2004, PKS also caught several favorable public opinion and social currents.
Following US president George W Bush's invasion of Iraq, PKS warnings against
excessive American influence played well. That's a far less potent issue with
US President Barack Obama, who has pledged to withdraw US troops from Iraq and
spent his youth in Jakarta. The Iraq invasion also fed a tide of Muslim
victimization in 2004, and supporting radical Islam at the ballot box was a
relatively harmless way to assert religious pride and strike a blow against the
oppressors.
But the tide turned against radical Islam following the 2005 Bali bombings, the
first verified suicide bombings in Indonesia. No one in Indonesia is against
Islam, but mainstream opinion turned against radical Islam and Islamists after
the incident. Yudhoyono's administration, which follows public opinion far more
than leads it, felt comfortable enough to denounce sharia measures
enacted locally (though it hasn't moved to repeal any of them). More visibly,
it carried out the executions of three convicted 2002 Bali bombers late last
year. None of the feared Islamist backlash followed.
In its election platform this time, PKS is attempting to tap into Islamist
populism by pledging support for Palestinians. While few Indonesians oppose
Palestinian aspirations, the issue is unlikely to be a big vote getter in a
country that still suffers from rampant poverty and unemployment and faces
slowing growth or worse as the global economic crisis slashes demand for its
exports.
Yudhoyono's presidency has set a climate in tune with Indonesia's go-along,
get-along national ethos. He's successfully lowered the political temperature
that was running far hotter in 2004 after having four presidents in six years,
or two more than in the republic's previous 44-year history. In Yudhoyono's
Indonesia of incremental reform, radical solutions are out.
Even with the electoral stars seemingly aligned against it, PKS still could
surprise, as it did in 2004. "PKS is still a substantial party, but without the
focus that it had in its early days," Witoelar says. "Still, it has more
emotional content than most parties and has mobilizing capability because of
its access to modern communications technology." But Witoelar admits, "I have
no idea how it will fare."
Longtime editor of investor rights advocate eRaider.com, Gary LaMoshihas
written for Slate and Salon.com, and works as a counselor for Writing Camp
(www.writingcamp.net). He first visited Indonesia in 1994 and has been going
back ever since.
(Copyright 2009 Asia Times Online (Holdings) Ltd. All rights reserved. Please
contact us about
sales, syndication and
republishing.)
Head
Office: Unit B, 16/F, Li Dong Building, No. 9 Li Yuen Street East,
Central, Hong Kong Thailand Bureau:
11/13 Petchkasem Road,
Hua Hin, Prachuab Kirikhan, Thailand 77110
