Trade stalls across divided Kashmir
By Athar Parvaiz
SRINAGAR - Trade and travel between the Indian and Pakistan parts of Kashmir
allowed to a limited extent as part of confidence-building measures between the
two rival countries appear to have become a casualty of the terror attacks last
November on India's financial center of Mumbai.
This is despite Indian Foreign Minister Pranab Mukherjee immediately after the
attacks vowing that the "Kashmir-centric" confidence-building measures would
not be affected by the terror strikes, which left 180 people dead.
Trade between the divided parts of Kashmir, which had started in
October 2008 but was struggling thanks to the lack of infrastructure and
facilities, might have improved but for the renewed acrimony between India and
Pakistan over the Mumbai attacks, according to traders.
Over the past three years, India and Pakistan began a number of
confidence-building measures as part of a peace process. These included the
reopening of the Srinagar-Muzaffarabad highway, sealed since 1947 when the
disputed territory was carved up between India and Pakistan.
In 2005, India and Pakistan agreed to reopen the highway to allow families
divided by the Line of Control (LoC), the de facto border, to cross to meet
their kith and kin. By 2008, warming relations between the two countries
allowed the opening of the road across the LoC to trade as well.
The volume of trade cross the rugged terrain was limited and on a barter basis,
but traders in Srinagar appreciated the measure and had hopes that it would
expand with time.
"We were told that all the facilities regarding the facilitation of trade
between the two parts of Kashmir would be put in place by the end of 2008, but
nothing of the sort happened,'' Mubeen Shah, president of the Kashmir Chamber
of Commerce and Industry, told Inter Press Service (IPS).
"The fact is we are yet to settle the account of the trade items which we have
exchanged on the occasion of resumption of trade across the LoC on October 21,
2008.''
Several demands by the traders are pending. The most significant is the
restoration of telephone links between the divided parts of Kashmir and the
setting up of bank branches at cities such as Srinagar and Jammu in
Indian-administered Kashmir and Muzaffarabad and Mirpur in
Pakistan-administered Kashmir.
"The chief minister [of India-controlled Jammu and Kashmir] Omar Abdullah has
himself stated many times that trade across the LoC was meaningless unless
traders were able to exchange phone calls. The government should do some
practical work to ensure it,'' said Shah.
"Communication facilities for Kashmiris stand snapped for decades even as
people elsewhere in India and Pakistan can make or receive phone calls to each
other,'' said civil rights activist Hameeda Nayeem. ''People on this [Indian]
side of the divided Kashmir can only receive calls from the other side, but
can't make calls from here," she said.
Nayeem asserts that exchange of business ideas is a basic requirement for trade
to flourish. "And it has not been helpful for confidence-building that there
are no facilities to allow money transactions.''
Shah is worried by the fact that trade has been mostly confined to traders who
happen to have relations on the other side of the LoC. "This is mainly because
no trader wants to risk his goods. Traders need to be assured about costs and
profits. Since there is no security, traders hesitate to send across goods,''
Shah said.
"At present, the trade goes on only in a cosmetic and subdued manner. We are
having problems reconciling accounts. For example, our fruit growers sent fruit
worth three million rupees [US$58,600] in the first consignment, but they
didn't get what they consider the equivalent in return through the barter
system."
Observers expect no improvement on this front at least until general elections
in India slated for April are over as political parties focus more on rhetoric
than on peace-making with Pakistan.
"The present United Progressive Alliance [UPA] government [a coalition of more
than a dozen political parties led by the Congress party] - is wary of the
opposition alliance, the National Democratic Alliance led by the right-wing,
pro-Hindu Bhartiya Janata Party [BJP], which slams it for any softness
regarding Pakistan or Pakistan-backed Kashmiri pro-freedom leadership," said
political analyst Noor Baba.
"At this point in time, the UPA government would not like to take any risks
which may give a handle to the BJP as the parties gear up for the elections,''
Baba said. ''It would rather focus on those issues which would better its
prospects in the general elections."
The Indian government is putting pressure on Pakistan to do more on the Mumbai
terror strikes. India believes the plan was entirely orchestrated in Pakistan,
and Islamabad recently admitted that the plan was partially devised there.
"The Indian government cannot afford to relent and will try its best to sustain
the pressure so as to better its chances in the upcoming elections," Baba told
IPS. ''The Congress-led coalition government has to do this in order to deny
leverage to the BJP."
The chances of the Indian government resuming peace talks with Kashmiri
separatist leaders appear bleak, especially after the successful conclusion of
state assembly elections.
During her recent visit to Kashmir, UPA chairperson Sonia Gandhi called on
separatist leaders to take part in the democratic process, indicating the
"massive people's participation" in the assembly elections - which saw a
coalition of the Omar Abdullah-led National Conference and Gandhi's Congress
party coming to power.
The central government and pro-India political parties were encouraged by the
good voter turnout in Kashmir, especially when the elections were held amid a
wave of anti-India sentiment triggered by the allotment of land to a Hindu
shrine board in May 2008. Dozens of people were killed and hundreds injured in
protests and clashes that followed.
Kashmir continues to simmer. On February 22, two youths were shot dead and
another seriously injured allegedly without provocation by security forces.
Earlier in the month, a youth was killed in Lolab, north Kashmir, and another
in Kuil-Pulwama.
These killings have led to demands by political parties and rights activists
for the revocation of the draconian Armed Forces Special Powers Act. "The
special powers give the security forces a sense of impunity and they go to any
extent, including killing of innocent people,'' said Mehbooba Mufti, leader of
the opposition Peoples' Democratic Party.
Head
Office: Unit B, 16/F, Li Dong Building, No. 9 Li Yuen Street East,
Central, Hong Kong Thailand Bureau:
11/13 Petchkasem Road, Hua Hin, Prachuab Kirikhan, Thailand 77110
