Search Asia Times

Advanced Search

 
Middle East

Allawi struggles for acceptance
By Dahr Jamail

BAGHDAD - The interim Iraqi prime minister is following in the footsteps of the previous president. The rule of US-appointed Iyad Allawi is now more in the style of the dictatorship of Saddam Hussein than a leader of a supposedly democratic state.

Most Iraqis celebrated the overthrow of the regime of Saddam. But under what has developed into a brutal and bloody occupation, people are turning against Allawi as they turned against Saddam - some even call him "Saddam without a mustache".

One of Allawi's earliest moves after his appointment in May was to form a new version of the feared secret police in Iraq. The Economist reported that Allawi's rivals accused him of "recruiting former torturers to man a new apparatus of oppression".

In July, Paul McGeogh of the Sydney Morning Herald reported that two witnesses saw Allawi execute six people at the security center in the al-Amadiyah district of Baghdad. The men had been detained for allegedly attacking US forces two weeks before the handover of power on June 28.

The appointed interim prime minister has instituted martial law, threatened to detain journalists and banned the Arab channel al-Jazeera from reporting within Iraq. Allawi's minister of justice has brought back the death penalty and spoken of chopping off the hands and heads of those described as insurgents.

Then came the siege of Fallujah. At a refugee camp in Baghdad filled with families from the besieged city, anger erupts at the mention of Allawi's name. "Allawi says we are his family," said Mohammad Ali, a 53-year-old refugee wounded by US bombs in his home in Fallujah. "Can you attack your family, Allawi? Do you attack your own family, Allawi?"

"Allawi is a traitor to the people of Iraq," said Dr Um Mohammed, who works at a hospital in Baghdad. "He is an American puppet who enjoys the killing of Iraqis." A trader in central Baghdad, Abdel Hakim Abdulla, said Allawi has "never made a decision that benefits Iraqis".

Anger is building up against Allawi also over the role he played before he was appointed interim prime minister. He is the man many hold responsible for providing fraudulent intelligence that Saddam posed a threat to the US. His now-discredited statements to US intelligence that Saddam had links to the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, were used to justify the invasion of Iraq. This had shaken his credibility among Iraqis from the beginning.

The right-wing Daily Telegraph of London published a "newly discovered" document from Allawi of last December 14. Allawi, who was then a member of the Iraqi Governing Council (IGC), stated that the mastermind of the September 11 terrorist attacks, Mohammad Atta, had been trained in Iraq with support from Saddam. This fraudulent information was cited by US intelligence as compelling evidence that Saddam had contacts with al-Qaeda. It was cited as justification for the failing occupation of Iraq.

A second part of the memo also believed to have been provided by Allawi alleged the shipment of uranium from Niger to Iraq. This is another claim that has been proved false.

Allawi was reported by the International Herald Tribune to have said that Saddam had stashed billions of dollars in banks around the world. No evidence of these billions has emerged. Allawi was said again to have provided the "intelligence" in a British government dossier that Iraq had weapons of mass destruction that could be made operational in 45 minutes, according to a report in the New York Times of May 29. This "intelligence" has been acknowledged to be false.

Allawi, a Shi'ite Muslim, was "unanimously nominated" to the post of interim prime minister on May 28 by the US-appointed former IGC.

Adam Daifallah wrote in the New York Sun that Allawi heads a group comprising primarily former Ba'athist associates of Saddam and "has received funding from the CIA [Central Intelligence Agency of the United States] and has unsuccessfully worked with American intelligence for years to oust Saddam through coup attempts".

Born in Baghdad in 1946 into a well-known business family, Allawi became a member of the Ba'ath Party after it rose to power. He left Iraq in 1971 to go to university in London, and did not return to his home country until just after the US-led invasion last year.

Allawi's father was a member of the Iraqi parliament. His grandfather helped negotiate Iraq's independence from Britain.

But Allawi's own political start was marked by reversals. He entered politics by becoming a student organizer for the Ba'ath Party while he attended medical school in Baghdad in the 1960s. The party - marked by its readiness to take and keep power by force - took part in overthrowing one Iraqi government in 1963 before being deposed itself. After launching a second coup in 1968, the Ba'athists stayed in power until the US-led overthrow of Saddam. That early political history worries some Iraqis, who today often distrust anyone once closely tied to the Ba'ath Party.

Dr Abdul Sahib Hakim is an Iraqi human-rights activist in London who knows Allawi well. He assesses Allawi's early Ba'athist days this way: "This is the weakest point, or the [most] dangerous point of his life. I received a lot of calls from inside Iraq, I have been in Iraq five times since the fall of the dictator Saddam, and they don't like the Ba'ath Party members at all, even the ex-members."

Allawi's supporters describe the move to London as an "exile" from Saddam, but some of his former associates say he continued to work for the Ba'athists in Europe. Then, in 1975, he had an unspecified falling out with the party and - three years later - was nearly killed by an assassin presumed to be a Saddam agent.

By 1990, Allawi had become the leader of his own exile party, recruiting former and disaffected Ba'athists. His Iraqi National Accord (INA) attempted a CIA-backed coup against Saddam in 1996. But Saddam's agents detected the conspiracy and many of the officers who were supposed to lead their troops against the regime were killed.

Mahmoud Othman is an independent Kurdish politician who was a member of the IGC. He says that when the US handed over political power to Iraq's first post-Saddam sovereign government in June, Allawi received the post of prime minister because of his security experience.

"When the Americans proposed Allawi through the Governing Council, we had a majority for Allawi and we supported him," he said. "We preferred him over the other candidates because of one main reason. He was responsible for security in the Governing Council and he was the head of the joint security committee between us and the Americans at the time. So, because the main problem we had was security, we thought he may be the best of these people to deal with these issues."

One of Allawi's first moves after becoming interim prime minister was to announce that Saddam would be tried in Iraq. He said that Saddam would receive a fair trial and that the proceedings would mark a firm break with the past.

"Well, [the trial] will show that justice will prevail, ultimately, regardless of how long it will take to be implemented. We would like to show the world, also, that the new Iraqi government means business and wants to do business and wants to stabilize Iraq and put it on the route and the road to democracy and peace."

But some observers say that if Allawi hopes to convince Iraqis fully that they are in charge of their own destiny, he will have to overcome several major challenges. Among the biggest of these is winning widespread domestic approval for his unelected interim government. Many analysts call such approval crucial if the government is to play a larger role in securing the country - a task now in the hands of the US-led coalition forces.

Former IGC member Othman says Allawi's government has yet to demonstrate that it can reach out to ordinary Iraqis. "When this government came to power, people were expecting good things from it. But what happened is that the Iraqi administration couldn't get away from the American control. They are all living in one area which is totally protected by the Americans, called the Green Area. They should have tried to reach the people, to go to the provinces, to see their own people, to talk to them, to see what are the problems, and try to isolate the [hardcore Saddam loyalists and] terrorists from the other type of people who are not satisfied, who are against occupation, who are [reacting to the daily activities of the Americans.] Instead of that ... [they] were touring countries outside."

Allawi's government is charged with taking the country to a first round of elections in January to select a transitional National Assembly. The National Assembly is to choose a transitional government to lead the country to direct election of a representative government by the end of next year.

(Inter Press Service)

(Additional reporting by Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty.)


Nov 24, 2004
Asia Times Online Community



The Sunni-Shi'ite power play
(Nov 20, '04)

Resistance looks beyond Fallujah
(Nov 19, '04)

Counterinsurgency run amok
(Nov 18, '04)

Allawi barking up the wrong tree
(Sep 22, '04)

 

 
   
         
No material from Asia Times Online may be republished in any form without written permission.
Copyright 2003, Asia Times Online, 4305 Far East Finance Centre, 16 Harcourt Rd, Central, Hong Kong