The (propaganda) empire strikes in China
By Kent Ewing
HONG KONG - When seven-foot, six-inch Yao Ming dunks a basketball, does the
world smile on China? When pianist Lang Lang, the Chinese Liberace, sparkles in
concert, does China's political star glow a little brighter in the firmament of
nations? And when Hong Kong tycoon Li Ka-shing, the richest person of Chinese
descent in the world, banks another billion dollars on shrewd investments, is
the image of the Chinese nation also enriched?
That's what China's leaders are hoping for as they enlist 50 Chinese
celebrities in an unprecedented international advertising campaign to improve
the country's global image. The charm offensive is set to begin this September,
ahead of celebrations for
61st birthday of the People's Republic of China (PRC) on October 1, and will
also feature Olympic diving diva Guo Jingjing, film director John Woo and movie
star Jackie Chan. The famous 50 will appear in 30-second television commercials
as well as a 15-minute promotional film selling China's virtues to the rest of
the world.
In the words of the State Council, China's cabinet, the campaign will present
an image of "prosperity, democracy, openness, peace and harmony" as a counter
to the negative stereotypes about the country that its leaders have long blamed
the Western media for promulgating. How effective this strike will be, however,
remains highly uncertain.
For years now, Beijing has been struggling to use its so-called "soft power" to
raise its global image, aiming to match its growing economic clout with a
heightened appreciation of Chinese culture and political ideals. This glitzy
international celebrity troupe is just the latest public-relations gambit in a
strained, ongoing effort that has, so far, fallen flat. While there is no
question that China's remarkable economic success over the past 30 years has
stunned the world, a recent BBC poll shows that people in an increasing number
of countries have a negative view of China's rise.
Yet this is the country that, in 2008, staged what were arguably the most
successful Olympic Games ever and is currently hosting the World Expo in its
gloriously reborn financial center, Shanghai. The frustrated Chinese leadership
team, from President Hu Jintao on down, must be scratching their heads and
wondering what they have to do to earn some international respect.
After all, other polls show that Chinese people, both in China and in the vast
Chinese diaspora, have never been more patriotic. They clearly think it's cool
to be Chinese in the 21st century in the same way that it was cool to be
American in the 20th. When, they wonder, will the rest of the world catch on?
The celebrity-powered promotional campaign is intended to convince the doubting
global public that the Chinese model, from top to bottom, is worthy of
admiration and emulation. But it, like all previous efforts to present a false
image of the country, is doomed to fail until the new, economically triumphant
China drops its geriatric propaganda strategies and truly engages the
international community in an honest dialogue.
For several years now, Beijing has been engaged in a public-relations blitz in
a multiplicity of languages. Confucius Institutes teaching Chinese language and
culture have sprouted up across the world while state media have greatly
expanded their global reach.
Last year alone, the central government spent 45 billion yuan (US$6.6 billion)
to increase the international influence of the Xinhua News Agency, China
Central Television (CCTV) and China Radio International (CRI). CCTV added a
Russian-language service and an Arabic-language channel that reaches 300
million people in 22 countries. CRI can now be heard in 43 different languages,
and Xinhua is adding 117 bureaus around the world.
In addition, last year saw Chinese leaders welcome international media bigwigs
such as News Corp chief Rupert Murdoch and the former British Broadcasting
Cooperation's former executive, Richard Sambrook to the Great Hall of the
People in Beijing for the first World Media Summit, dubbed the "Media
Olympics". It also witnessed the international launch of the English-language
version of the Global Times, as well as a US edition of China Daily, the
primary English-language mouthpiece for the Chinese government.
In July, Xinhua launched CNC World, a global English-language news channel that
is modeled on CNN, the BBC and al-Jazeera, with one significant exception: its
total lack of objectivity on any story even remotely related to China.
But apparently this extravagantly expensive media onslaught was not enough to
win the world's affection. So now Yao, Lang, Li and a host of celebrity
comrades have been asked to do their part to soften the global image of China.
And there is every reason to expect that they will do a superb job in a slick
production that makes an irresistibly strong case for their rising nation.
Remember, this is the country that last week surpassed Japan as the second
largest economy in the world and that for three decades has averaged
double-digit annual growth, lifting tens of millions of people out of abject
poverty and into the middle class. There's a lot to brag about.
The problem, however, is that, no matter how winning the new promotional
campaign turns out to be, China will also continue to make news in a variety of
unflattering ways. While it is true that Beijing often does not get a fair
shake in the Western media - China-bashing and fear-inspired stereotypes abound
- that is not the main reason for all those negative poll ratings.
Let's face it: it's hard for the world to warm to a country that is the only
friend and supporter of regimes such as that of Kim Jong-il in North Korea and
Robert Mugabe in Zimbabwe. Chinese leaders have stood by Kim as his country
defied international sanctions to develop nuclear weapons. Beijing also
single-handedly blocked a condemnation of North Korea by the United Nations
Security Council (UNSC) for a torpedo attack last March that sank the South
Korean naval vessel, Cheonan, killing 46 sailors.
Just this month, the 86-year-old Mugabe, who has ruled Zimbabwe since 1987,
made yet another pilgrimage to Great Hall of the People, where he was greeted
as an old friend by Hu. Mugabe followed up his hobnobbing with Chinese leaders
in Beijing with a shopping spree in Hong Kong; meanwhile, his country is
falling apart, and his callous indifference to the plight of his people stands
as an affront to humanity.
Note that Chinese leaders did not ask Kim, Mugabe or any of Beijing's other
despot-buddies to make cameo appearances in their latest public-relations
bonanza. Nor will there be any mention of China's support for another
international pariah, Myanmar, whose military junta has held the country's
rightfully elected leader, Aung San Suu Kyi, under house arrest for 14 of the
last 20 years.
At home, the leadership's heavy-handed suppression of protests in the restive
regions of Tibet and Xinjiang continues to draw international opprobrium and,
underscoring the wrongheadedness of Beijing's approach, serves only to further
alienate the people of those regions from the central government and to flame
even more dissent.
In the end, the greatest self-defeating irony of China's global media blitz is
the shackles that its leaders place on national media and the great firewall of
censorship they have attempted to erect in cyberspace. China's state propaganda
machine may be reaching out to the world, but an army of censors at home is
busy blocking the world from reaching China. This was the harsh lesson learned
by Internet giant Google this year when its China contract was threatened by a
censorship dispute that ended with no guarantee that the central government
will not continue to censor the company's China website.
Kent Ewing is a Hong Kong-based teacher and writer. He can be reached at
kewing@hkis.edu.hk
(Copyright 2010 Asia Times Online (Holdings) Ltd. All rights reserved. Please
contact us about
sales, syndication and
republishing.)
Head
Office: Unit B, 16/F, Li Dong Building, No. 9 Li Yuen Street East,
Central, Hong Kong Thailand Bureau:
11/13 Petchkasem Road, Hua Hin, Prachuab Kirikhan, Thailand 77110
