SPEAKING FREELY Sticking it up Vladimir the Impaler By Nicolai N Petro
Speaking Freely is an Asia Times Online feature that allows guest writers to have
their say.
Please click hereif you are interested in
contributing.
Among Russian President Vladimir Putin's many sins, surely the most outrageous
is that he dares to compare Russia to the West. He has clearly forgotten
Russia's proper role in our Narrative of Western Civilization: to serve as a
poignant example of all the
sins that we never commit. Putin has the temerity to suggest that Russia and
the West face similar problems, and the gall to think that the West could even
learn a thing or two from Russia.
Quite understandably the US media have responded to such insolence with a
collective "ecrasez l'infame!" After the Group of Eight summit on July
19, the venerable Times of London politely
told Putin that we Westerners didn't appreciate his wisecracks about the
scandals surrounding Lord Levy (Prime Minister Tony Blair's chief fundraiser,
dubbed "Lord Cashpoint") or democracy in Iraq. "A little more grace, and less
hubris," if you please, wrote The Times.
Hear, hear! The last thing any of us needs is to hear about corruption,
criminality, and violence in our own countries. Why, the next thing you know
Putin will discover racism in some benighted corner of our enlightened lands
and start quoting Samuel Johnson at Americans: "How is it that we hear the
loudest yelps for liberty among the drivers of Negroes?"
The Times editorial quite properly pointed out that, as host at the G8, it was
quite ungracious of Putin to give voice to such piffle. As every civilized
person knows, the mark of true gentility is to attack your guest at a private
dinner in his honor, as the president of the European Parliament, Josep
Borrell, did at recent the EU-Russia summit in Lahti, Finland.
According the Italian daily La Stampa, Borrell introduced his guest by
sarcastically remarking that "we should be thanking Putin for closing the
pipelines to Ukraine last January, which has brought us here to talk about
energy". From there he spoke movingly of his concern for human rights,
non-governmental organizations and the free press (only in Russia, of course).
"We buy oil from the worst countries," he added sadly, "but we don't ask them
to share our values."
What subtlety! What grace! What a coincidence that his remarks at an event
closed to the press were leaked in time for the morning editions.
Putin, though, has still not learned to sit quietly and bow his head in shame.
First, he slyly admitted that he too was concerned about crime, but then added
that surely Russia wasn't the only country that had such problems. What about
the recent criminal indictments of several Spanish mayors, and oh, by the way,
"The mafia was not born in Russia."
One could have heard a fork drop on the fine linen tablecloth. The 25 European
Union leaders who had gathered to gang up on the Russian president that evening
could scarcely believe their ears. Once again Putin had violated one of the
cardinal principles of our relations with Russia by comparing his problems to
ours.
The danger in such behavior should be apparent to all. If Russia's problems are
seen as in any sense comparable to our own, then it can no longer be excluded
from Western institutions on the basis of its cultural incompatibility, and
what else is really left?
Militarily, as everyone knows, Russia is but a shadow of the former Soviet
Union. It poses so little threat that when Georgia seized four Russian military
officers, the Russian parliament responded by speeding up the withdrawal of its
remaining forces. Georgian Minister of Defense Irakli Okruashvili now regularly
dares Russia to try to invade his country.
Economically Russia has done better, but its foreign investments overseas still
put it on a par with Malaysia. As an energy provider, Russia supplies Europe
with about a quarter of its natural gas, but this is two-thirds of Russia's gas
exports, so that actually Russia is far more dependent on its European
consumers than they are on it.
Putin's wily retorts pose a real and present danger to the West, however,
precisely because they erode the sharp distinction between Western and Russian
identity, between Western and Russian values, that are needed to safeguard
Western Unity.
If this distinction disappears, pray tell, how will we be able to sustain our
fear of Russia? If Russia's domestic debates are likened to our own, or if the
Western press should begin reporting about all the areas of cultural, economic
and political similarities that already exist between Russia and the West, I
ask you, how will we preserve a proper sense of Russia's fundamental alienness?
Will we still be able to distinguish clearly between the perfectly tolerable
levels of corruption, intolerance, and violence in the West and the totally
intolerable levels of the same in Russia? In Russia's reflection, might not our
own domestic and foreign policies soon begin appear less than ideal?
This is a very slippery slope. Ultimately, such thinking could lead to
questions about whether "Western values" are truly the best for all nations at
all times. The faint-hearted among us might even be drawn to consider the
possibility of cross-cultural dialogue about the meaning and political
usefulness of such terms as "democracy" and "human rights".
Down this treacherous path one can envisage multilateral initiatives, based on
more culturally inclusive definitions of democracy, taking the place of the
tried and true strategies of "regime change" and "democratic-values education"
promoted by the administration of US President George W Bush. Perish the
thought!
That is why it is of such vital importance that Putin's uppity attitude be
firmly swatted down at every opportunity and why I, for one, applaud the
Western media for their diligence in this regard. The alternatives are simply
too awful to contemplate.
Nicolai N Petro served as the US State Department's special assistant for
policy on the Soviet Union under president George H W Bush, and now teaches
international politics at the University of Rhode Island.
told Putin that we Westerners didn't appreciate his wisecracks about the
scandals surrounding Lord Levy (Prime Minister Tony Blair's chief fundraiser,
dubbed "Lord Cashpoint") or democracy in Iraq. "A little more grace, and less
hubris," if you please, wrote The Times.
